But when the picture is ready, it prominently shows her birthmark, and so he throws it into acid. To cheer her up, he gives her a demonstration of his more elegant scientific abilities. Then shown is an ungrateful wife whom believes nothing she has is fit to wear to this event. Finally, in the end when Georgiana dies as a result of the quest for perfection, it is found that there is no such thing. In between his hours working on the treatment, Aylmer tells Georgiana about alchemy, the early branch of science that sought to turn various materials into gold. Aylmer tells her to pick it and smell its scent, because it will soon die and leave only its seeds to continue its existence on earth.
This particular character holds a philosophy that anything that is foreign is superior and anything indigenous as inferior. Especially considering her previous boyfriends had told her that the birthmark added to her charm. Instead of seeing it as a mark of uniqueness, he sees it as an imperfection. After reading both of the stories, it is clear that there were several literary elements used to portray the domestic responsibilities of women in society at the time. After returning the necklace the once before housewife had to now work and her husband for many years to replace what turned out to be a fake diamond necklace. Make sure to use the drop-down menu to save it under the assignment title.
She loves Aylmer more for his imperfections, even though he loves her less for hers. So most marriages were not based on love, but on social status. The story is about Aylmer, a brilliant scientist who is obsessed with science and is planning to use his experiments to remove a birthmark on the face of his wife Georgiana. And, even more interestingly, she isn't even upset about it. However, what could have been a sweet love story turns into a nightmare as Aylmer becomes obsessed with removing a small birthmark on Georgiana's cheek. He is not deep nor complex, but is simply the vehicle for Hawthorne to use to communicate his message. She actually has this basic anxiety because of the fact that she has this feeling of insecurity.
Interestingly, the main character, Aylmer, is obsessed with nature and perfection yet in a vain attempt to create something perfect, he only destroys it. The allusion is that Alymer looks at Georgian as being almost perfect, without the birthmark she would be the epitome of Godly perfection. He is very fair - he tries to hear both sides of an. Whenever the couple should be happy, Aylmer ends up talking about the birthmark, until it becomes the center of their marriage. Laugh, thing of the senses! As Georgiana studies the various aspects of her husband's profession she finds herself captivated by what he can do.
They then begin a long journey, fighting the supernatural and helping others along the way with the help of a family friend named Bobby Singer Jim Beaver , searching for the demon who killed their mother. GradeSaver, 10 September 2016 Web. These characters are, however, archetypes, and as archetypal characters they stand to present larger meanings and themes within the short story by Nathaniel Hawthorne. A symbol is an object or a person that represents important ideas. Hawthorne calls the birthmark 'a token of human imperfection;' he also noted that nature marks all her creations with some such flaw.
When the mark is removed there will be no distinguishable image in the reflection, for, having obtained perfection, she will transcend the earthly world. Thanks to Faithless Juliet for reviewing this; I kept what you wrote in mind when revising this. The couple moves to his apartment where he performs his scientific experiments. This is the first indication that Georgiana feels unsatisfied with her own morality, rather than just wanting to be rid of the birthmark because Aylmer hates it. The debate is whether Bartleby has good or bad traits, as you read the story you can easily go out and say Bartleby is an awful individual with no work ethic and is very disrespectful. While Aylmer works, Georgiana reads the books in his laboratory, which recount the achievements of famous scientists throughout history.
Georgiana wakes and sees her reflection in a mirror. He might be changing her very physical composition, but she seems fine with it, submitting entirely to his every whim. However, Aylmer seems to be failing so far. Instead, at her death Georgiana's soul will be purged of her sins and finally allowed to achieve perfection. In fact, his union with Georgiana would even have joined him to a divine being. In this activity, students will identify themes and symbols from the story, and support their choices with details from the text.
It also criticizes Aylmer for his unnecessary obsession with the mark. He has also caused Georgiana to begin hating herself, even though she has never minded the birthmark before. They argued for many changes with one of them being a social change in their duties to be subdominant to males. All I think can easily be misunderstood as true, but through all this I think Bartleby is utilizing a skill of his. Bartleby is hired to be a copyist for a lawyers firm, in fact the lawyer is the narrator of this short story. When he does create a potion to eliminate the birthmark, Georgiana dies. She understands exactly what happened with the birthmark and exactly why she has to die.
Georgiana asks if it might be possible to remove it, acknowledging that the attempt could be dangerous. This short story takes place on Wall Street in New York City and it takes place in the year of 1853. Aylmer finds Georgiana reading his books and scolds her for it, saying that reading his journal almost makes him go crazy, but Georgiana assures Aylmer that it has only increased her admiration of him. Aylmer is considered a great scientist, yet his journal reveals that his biggest successes were actually failures, that he was never able to exert the control over nature that he wanted. Aylmer experiences a brief moment of oblivious happiness, thinking he has created perfection, but Georgiana senses that not all is as it should be.